Your customer base isn't uniform — some customers place one order and never return, while others become repeat buyers who spend more per order with zero acquisition cost. Understanding this split is fundamental to profitable growth. The difference between a merchant who focuses acquisition dollars indiscriminately and one who invests in retention is often 200-300 basis points of margin. This feature breaks down your new versus returning customer metrics, calculates your repeat purchase rate, and shows you the true lifetime value drivers in your store.
Returning customers are dramatically more profitable than new customers, but not because they spend more per order — it's because you don't pay acquisition costs to bring them back. A returning customer at $80 AOV with zero acquisition cost beats a new customer at $100 AOV where you spent $30 to acquire them. Over a year, a customer who orders twice costs half as much per dollar of revenue as a customer who orders once.
This creates a strategic question: if you're running 8% POAS on new customer acquisition, but your repeat customers have a 35% contribution margin, you should be allocating more budget to retention. The merchants winning on profitability aren't necessarily running the highest revenue — they're optimizing the customer mix. A store with 35% repeat purchase rate and disciplined discount strategy will outprofit a store with 20% repeat rate and aggressive acquisition spending, even if the second store has higher topline revenue.
Every order is automatically categorized based on Shopify's customer history: new customers have zero prior orders, returning customers have placed at least one previous order. The chart below shows your revenue split and the trend over time — watch for the percentage of new orders rising or falling as an early indicator of acquisition velocity changes or retention improvements.
% of customers who ordered more than once — target 25%+ for sustainable growth
Every 0.1 increase compounds over 12 months — 1.6 to 1.7 is 6% more lifetime value
63% of total — high %, which means acquisition is still a lever; typical range 55-70%
37% of total; returning customers have 18% higher AOV despite lower volume
Once you see your customer mix, profit optimization becomes tactical. A merchant with 30% returning customer revenue and a 20% repeat purchase rate has found their answer: invest in post-purchase email, build community, reduce friction on repeat orders. A merchant with 50% returning revenue but only 12% repeat rate has a different problem — strong product-market fit but ineffective communication. The data shows you where to focus.
New customer discount (WELCOME10, -15%) to drive acquisition. No discount for returning customers — they don't need incentive to repurchase if you built the right product.
If returning customers are 40% of revenue with zero acquisition cost, your new customer acquisition budget should reflect that returning customers are already 40% of your sales floor.
Repeat purchase rate is the single best metric for email effectiveness. A 2% increase in repeat rate is often worth more than doubling ad spend.
If returning customers have 30% higher AOV, test tiered pricing, bundles, or upsells specifically for repeat buyers who already trust you.
Free plan. No credit card. Install in 60 seconds.
Install Free on Shopify